VituVingiSana wrote:FY2021 results were awful.
EPS 13.98
DPS 3.00
DPR 22%
ROE 6.3% (below inflation!)
PB: 20%
The story they are selling:
- Large losses in 4Q2021
- 4.5bn to be spent on expansion
- "Digital Bank"
- Pricing model
The reality is that DTB has done wrong by its shareholders.
The dilemma is the price is so low and one needs to absorb the loss and consider it as a potential "new" investment.
Awful. Awful. Awful.
I wonder if it makes sense to hold on or buy ar today's prices.
That's the analysis I need to work on.
Ask yourself whether management's interests are aligned with yours or not. Probably not. DTB does NOT exist to maximise shareholder value through the normal route of share price appreciation and dividends.
Instead it is a deposit pooling mechanism for some key constituents. They are encouraged to bank with DTB to get very high interest rates on their deposits and also to access some jumbo-sized business loans. Very frequently the latter go belly up.
Check how much is paid as interest expenses. Very high. Those are the main stakeholders.
Check the level of bad loan provisioning. Very high. Possibly to also minimise taxes as far as possible.
Check how much is paid to staff. Very low compared to banks of similar size.
Check how much is paid to 'shareholders' in the form of dividends. Very low to keep high cash levels for the true stakeholders.
Now, that said. I am buying some DTB shares because they are super cheap and I am holding out that some day in future the interests of the true shareholders will prevail.