Wazua
»
Investor
»
Stocks
»
Prediction: NSE Index will be sub 2,000 by year's end.
Rank: Member Joined: 12/9/2006 Posts: 186
|
I strongly believe that Kenya is yet to experience the global recession. This will become evident after the Budget exposes huge gaps. What will follow is a massive recession followed by further collapse in the NSE.
Next to collapse will be Kenyan shilling thus prompting the few remaining foreign investors(including Kenyans in diaspora) to pull out of the market. Then is when the NSE will really take a nose-dive to sub 2,000.
Meanwhile,the political infightings within the coalition of thieves will intesify as the lame duck general kiguoya watches from his slumber at State House. There will be a return of street demos as people get fed up with this coalition.
I welcome opinions from both sides of the argument,just make sure your opinions are backed by some reasoning,not insults.
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 10/17/2008 Posts: 1,234
|
@Tusker Baridi
We would be most obliged if you would first kindly back up your belief with reasoning and facts.
And while you are at it please also let us know why you are still interested in a country you advised everyone to flee.
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 6/26/2008 Posts: 319
|
Uhuru is already warning of a possible 500,000 jobs to be lost soon as the recession hits - meaning according to information he now has,the recession has not hit Kenya as yet..
So @Mpenzi and others,dont just brush this aside,bring forth some arguments for or against this topic and let us see where it goes. I wont run from Kenya as Tusker may have mentioned,but I know what he is saying here has reasonable possibility of taking place.
So,if we lose the 500,000 jobs,and the political 'circus' continues,wont u be ready to demonstrate on the streets of nairobi demanding action? I know I might be by then.....so @tusker,maybe u r right.
If 500,000 jobs are lost - from employers some of whom are on the NSE,companies will not be performing well enough for any reasonable gains/profits/dividends to be forthcoming - it makes sense then that maybe under 2,000 is a real possibility.
That is the pessimistic/realistic me speaking - I prefer to think positive that we are already in the recession and by the time we now officially realise it,we will already be coming out of it...so maybe.....either way could be true.
Bidii yangu
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 2/12/2008 Posts: 345
|
Theory. A good theory. Best of wishes.
The race is not always to the swift..nor the battle always to the strong..nor food always to the wise..nor riches always to the intelligent..favor is not always to the skilled..or learned..but time and chance happens to all. Ecl9:5..
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 2/27/2007 Posts: 2,768
|
Personally,i think the prediction is right this time round. As i stated elsewhere,i expect it to go down to just about 1700 albeit gradually before the end of the year. The main reasons are incompetent and corrupt stock brokers (remember the forensic audit carried out on Nyaga Stock Brokers and the involvement of NSE,CMA,and the CDSC in its operations just before its collapse,now Discount has gone under,Suntra is sickly and God knows who is to follow),there is very little fresh money going into NSE (in any case investors are running away from the NSE) and the high stock prices are therefore unsustainable,there is a confidence crisis at NSE mainly due to current political status,and the broker malpractices and lastly we have not been hit by the global financial crisis proper (i expect this to be having a disastrous effect on NSE as investors will take a high ground and watch as the prices tumble as they hold on to their cash)... NEVER TALK OF A RHINO IF THERE IS NO TREE NEAREBY - ZULU PROVERB ...besides, the presence of a safe alone does not signify that there is money inside...
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 10/18/2008 Posts: 3,434 Location: Kerugoya
|
We have just had a spike. Somebody made some good money. It is now pointing south but will be back soon. The analysts and fundamentalists may keep away but for the adrenalin guys and those who fly by the seat of their pants,it is show time. Pick your seat and clasp on your belt. It is going to be wild and fun. Live hard,die hard.
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 6/17/2008 Posts: 294
|
Whether the NSE index reaches 2000 or 1700,one thing is sure! Speculators will still make cash! Bounces will never cease! Once a while bargain hunters will be flocking the market and create demand! Those who have learnt to ride the trends will sure benefit!
As Richard Branson said and as someone pointed out somewhere in this forum! This generation will surely create millionaires! It all depends on how smart someone is!
But you shall remember the LORD your God,for it is He who is giving you power to make wealth,that He may confirm His covenant which He swore to your fathers,as it is this day. Deu 8:18
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/9/2006 Posts: 186
|
Except for the usual suspects(mpenzi) I'm glad people are aproaching this thread with their emotions set aside. I think this global recession is godsend to those who play it right. My advice is to develop a vulture mentality; wait until the market has been shredded to bare bones and then move in to pick up the jewels from the carcass.
Meanwhile,preserve cash and dont be trigger happy,patience is key. Dont let the occassional dead cat bounce lure you back into the market. With the NSE manipulators(brokers),you cant win this game they're playing. They will try to lure you with a manipulated rally then get out before you can say sell,leaving you holding an empty bag.
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 3/6/2009 Posts: 172
|
I keep on wondering why people think that being careful(pessimistic) and being a good investor are mutually exclusive on this site.
There are already warnings that things are not too good.
Increase in retirement age - gov't can't pay lumpsomes now Borrowing even from Arabs - gov't is actually begging from all and sundry rising inflation - if the 25% inflation figure did not scare you,you need a lesson in economics Extra rosy pictures all around - Which company can claim that they are going to make supernormal profits. only enron Have you gone shopping lately with 1k? - What you bring back will tell you exactly what the market is doing
When markets are about to tank a few things happen and this happens all around the world not only in Kenya
Financial institutions start failing - I think this month an insurance firm,and a few brokers are in trouble. you really do not have to wait for a bank to fail too? Extra regulations - so this is the year that the gov't so it right to take care of the capital market authority? Fake bounces - If prices are going up or down for no particular reason,then someone is playing the market. If anyone can explain to me how Equity went up 40% in a week without telling me the usual 'its a good company nonsense',I will be willing to listen. All of a sudden everyone in gov't starts telling you how strong the economy is. - If its that good,they would not need to say anything Property Market stops growing - There is nothing like property values are the same as last year so things are fine. If you have a valuer who's your friend,ask them if they are valueing less property than same time last year. you should also ask them who their clients are. If it is buyers,that is different than if it is banks. I would suggest you get a property valuer as a friend and get him drunk. If his clients are now banks,then the bubble is about to burst.
However,there is the simple test you can do. If you are using more money this month to buy the same items as last month,then things are thick! You really do not have to be told that there is inflation or a recession. Just check your bank balance.
I think that Kenya is sitting on a time bomb especially because everyone is underestimating what this world problem is all about.
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 2/26/2008 Posts: 4,449
|
I don't think what you have listed is anything less than what we expected. So to assume the magnitude of the situation is not captured by current investors/pessimists is in itself negating your argument.
Question is are you assuming the markets are yet to tank solely based on what you have listed? If so,where do you suggest one keeps/invests any disposable income?
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 3/6/2009 Posts: 172
|
Sorry Ectacy,I am not going to be a porfolio manager today.
My point is that yes,the market has yet to tank as it should. But that is only my view.
It does not mean that I am not investing. You have to invest the extra even in bad times in order to stay ahead. All I am saying is that there needs to be a change in tack other than the usual gung ho investing experienced recently.
Being optimistic also involves reading the signs and making the proper adjustments. Don't jump into every rally in the market,yet the budget is only a few weeks away. Somehow you know what is it in it but you want to jump the line. That strategy only leads to sad days.
The market is a bear. Buying is not an investment strategy,it is a gamble. It will remain a bear for sometime. however,not having the required good name on sk,you are free to do as you wish. I know what I am doing and buying rallies is not one of my investment strategies.
If you are the only one buying and everyone else is selling,it is a bear market. Even if you have the money to buy the stocks.
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/9/2006 Posts: 186
|
@ectacy,I think the NSE index has not factored in the pending recession proper,that's why one needs to be very careful with one's money. As far as where to invest/park your money,I would advice anyone in Kenya to buy US dollars and just sit back and watch the shilling tank. Once you're certain the market has hit bottom(if you're lucky) then your dollar will buy more shares relative to the Kenyan shilling.
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 7/3/2007 Posts: 1,634
|
Tusker Baridi. I can be as pessimistic as the worst of them. However I disagree with your theory for the simple reason that you are mixing oranges with bananas and claiming to serve us mangoes. Consider: 1. Kenya is an agricultural (not manufacturing or even service) economy. Our real economic crisis comes when the agricultural sector is affected,by draught,by PEV,by mismanagement,name it. You could therefore say that we are just emerging from our 'global' economic crisis. 2. Any conflation of the financial melt down in the West with Kenyas mismanagement is wishful bunk that has so far gone unproven. Think about it: over 70% of our people are unbanked even at the best of times,yet the wheels of the Kenyan economy roll along. In the meantime Kenyan banks are declaring super-normal profits,laughing all the way to the,well,the bank. What financial melt down are you talking about? 3. The Nairobi stock exchange is an elite club that has very little to do with the larger economy. Granted these elites would like you to think that their fate is tied to that of the nation. Don't believe them. If the NSE disappeared today,with its 1 trillion shillings of paper wealth tell me what impact this would have on the peasant farmer in Kaksingiri? Yet it is that peasant farmer,and fisherman and herdsman and hawker and mama mboga who carry the weight of the Kenyan economy on her shoulders. So the global economic crisis will arrive on our shores and our pampered elite will cry as the NSE falls to 1700. Yawnnn.... Wake me up when something interesting happens. "The opposite of a correct statement is a false statement. But the opposite of a profound truth may well be another profound truth." (Niels Bohr)
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/9/2006 Posts: 186
|
Wakanyugi,lets talk.
1. Kenya is an agricultural economy,who do you think buys our produce? Have you seen the commodity market lately? If we're now just emerging from our economic crisis as you say,then we chose to do it at the worst time.
2. What financial meltdown are you talking about,I never talked of any financial meltdown,I'm talking about global recession. China and the rest of the non Western world did not partake in the financial shenanigans but guess what,their economies are getting hit by the contangion. China,which is flush with cash and has been growing at the rate of 15%,just had its growth rate projections reduced to 6.5% by World Bank.
3. Remember when the NSE used to be for the elites,well,it never went anywhere. What ressurected the NSE from its slumber were those retail investors,not the elites. Exit retail investors and NSE is just a dead and empty exclusive club.
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 3/31/2008 Posts: 7,081 Location: Kenya
|
..are we seeing this begin to happen. The Ksh in now at 81 to the USD
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 7/3/2007 Posts: 1,634
|
Wakanyugi,lets talk. 1. Kenya is an agricultural economy,who do you think buys our produce? Have you seen the commodity market lately? If we're now just emerging from our economic crisis as you say,then we chose to do it at the worst time. Tusker B: there you go mixing oranges and bananas again. True we sell our flowers and coffee and tea in the commodities markets. But the bottom-line effect on the peasant who toils all day to grow or pick them is limited. The real impact of this selling is: a) on foreign exchange reserves which helps the government b) on the - overseas - bank accounts of the multinationals who monopolies this trade. If Kenya were a welfare state you could claim that a positive impact on government accounts would be felt by Mwananchi. But we are not and it is not. The real economic impact on majority Kenyans will not come from the cyclical commodities markets. It comes when the price of unga and maziwa increase. Yes I know urbanites will scream but believe me the farmer in Kiambu with his one cow is smiling. 2. What financial meltdown are you talking about,I never talked of any financial meltdown,I'm talking about global recession. China and the rest of the non Western world did not partake in the financial shenanigans but guess what,their economies are getting hit by the contagion. China,which is flush with cash,just had its growth rate projections reduced to 6.5% by World Bank. China did not partake of the financial shenanigans of the rest of the world? You have been listening to Hu Jintao again haven't you? Tell me who is uncle Sam's biggest creditor? China. And is it not all this money flooding into the West from China and the Oil producing Middle East that encouraged irresponsible lending which triggered the financial melt down we are seeing? The only thing I find strange is that people have forgotten,we have been here before. After the OPEC crisis in the seventies a similar debt crisis hit the World in short order,only that time it was poor countries,not sub prime mortgage holders,who borrowed to the gills. The poor countries learned their lessons though. I could say much more on this subject but I suggest you take a look at the following titles: 'The Confessions of an Economic Hitman,' John Perkins and 'A fate Worse Than Debt,' Susan George. Back to our humble Jamuhuri,how much in US government paper does our Central Bank hold? How much exposure do our banks have to the toxic financial produces that are killing their peers out West? Zero to none,otherwise we would have seen the write downs. UK is looking for a bogeyman to blame for the governments incompetence so of course he points to the West and cries wolf. I am surprised that you would be duped too. 3. Remember when the NSE used to be for the elites,well,it never went anywhere. What resurrected the NSE from its slumber were those retail investors,not the elites. Exit retail investors and NSE is just a dead and empty exclusive club. I do not have the numbers here so I will not argue this point. But methinks this whole NSE,retail investor stuff is overrated. True the potential is there but we are not there yet. For instance,the US is planning to raise most of the trillions they need to fix their economy through the capital markets,much of that from the US itself. Could we ever do the same in Kenya? We recently collectively fell over in surprise when the government raised 18 billion bob through the infrastructure bond. One day we may have the same kind of Capital Markets (hopefully minus the NSE Ponzi scheme). Until then let us not baptize a cat and call it a lion. "The opposite of a correct statement is a false statement. But the opposite of a profound truth may well be another profound truth." (Niels Bohr)
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/9/2006 Posts: 186
|
Cmon Wakanyugi,you can do better than that.
1. This is stockskenya,not peasantskenya. I'm talking about the negative effect of a fall in commodity prices on stocks such as Mumias,Sasini,nakadhalika. These mustinationals that you're talking about make up the bulk of the traded stocks at the NSE.
2. China lending the US dollars is not financial shenanigan,its called prudent investing. Can you imagine if China had put its excess surplus into Euros or Pounds,they would have been massacred. There is a reason the dollar is gaining strenght relative to other currencies,its because the US guaranteed dollar is the safest instrument in this environment.
Now lets get back to the basics,the fundamentals of the Kenyan economy are weak and here's how the financial contagion will affect Kenya. Remember how Kenya always begs for money from the IMF to shore up budgetary gaps,well forget about that this year coz even the IMF is broke. Forget about getting soft loans from EU or States either as they are just as broke as we are.
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 7/3/2007 Posts: 1,634
|
1. This is stockskenya,not peasantskenya. This unfortunate admission goes to confirm what I have been saying so far. SK,NSE,CMA (chose your combination of letters) represents an elitist minority (less than 1 million people) who would like us to believe they are the lifeblood of Kenya's economy. They are not. Peasantkenya is where the action happens. We only reap the benefit. Take a look at any government revenue statement and you will see I am right. 2. China lending the US dollars is not financial shenanigan,its called prudent investing..... There is a reason the dollar is gaining strength relative to other currencies,its because the US guaranteed dollar is the safest instrument in this environment. This does not absolve the Chinese and the Arabs of responsibility for the global financial mess. It is their money that started it. The bankers who sold sub prime mortgages and then transferred the risk to other suckers,through all manner of products,could also argue that they were practicing prudent banking. After all what is the reason for a bank's existence? It is to make money. How? By: a) working the capital entrusted to them (which they list on the debit column of their ledger,BTW) enough to make a profit and b) reducing any risk to themselves as much as possible. The Western banks did everything right but got the risk equation wrong. Kenyan banks did not play. Does that make them wise and prudent? The only reason you can say China practiced prudent investing (by off shoring their excess receipts to avoid the Dutch disease) is because they did not get caught and the Westerners,who stupidly accepted to take on what should have been China's problem,did. So you think the US is the safest instrument to put your money in? Wait until America wakes up with a post stimulus hangover of the century and the rest of the World takes notice. Whom do you think will pay for mopping up all that money they are printing? I bet that all these trillion dollar programs will be unwound largely by exporting inflation to the rest of the World. Tell me I am wrong and prove it. 3. Now lets get back to the basics,the fundamentals of the Kenyan economy are weak and here's how the financial contagion will affect Kenya. Remember how Kenya.... well forget about that this year coz even the IMF is broke. A clarification here. I have not denied that we have a crisis and it might get worse. But ours is a crisis of mismanagement not economic collapse. Begging from the IMF,as we have done before,reflects mismanagement on the side of our government. Why do you think they place so many conditions on their miserly loans? And I maintain that as long as we have adequate rainfall and farmers,fishermen,market traders etc are not prevented from doing their thing,the fundamentals of Kenya's economy will remain sound. On this I am willing to bet anything. "The opposite of a correct statement is a false statement. But the opposite of a profound truth may well be another profound truth." (Niels Bohr)
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/9/2006 Posts: 186
|
Wakanyugi,please lets not digress from the issue at hand.
1. We can discuss peasants on another thread but this one is all about stocks,so enough with the peasants.
2. You're obviously out of your mind for likening China's investment in US bonds to Wallstreet financial shenanigans. That's like saying your peasant farmer is to blame for banking his exess cash with Equity bank should the later lose money coz of its loose lending practices.
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 3/6/2009 Posts: 172
|
Some of the arguments here sound straight from the Alfred Mutua rule book.
1. The Peasant farmer will not be affected by weakening commodity prices is the biggest lie I have ever heard. If coffee,Tea and even pyrethrum prices are falling,yes that farmer you are talking about is bound to feel it big time.
There is no special agricultural economy. Most Kenyan farmers now rely on exports of products to Europe. Europe Wakanyugi is not buying.
People there did not participate in sub prime but they are wise enough to tighten their belts.
2. The NSE depends on those retail or long term investors in order to grow. The continous failure of these brokers is not endearing the market to the commoner like me.
I guess only Equity can save this mob.
3. Debt in Govt
Please read this very carefully. Kenya gov't is borrowing. I hear City hall is also bankrupt.
The gov't has a budget to take care of. It will be filled one way or another. It will raise funds for their political pet projects whether you like it or not.
If it cannot borrow from WB or IMF it will borrow locally. More bonds are going to be issued. Taxes will be increased on each and every product imaginable this year. Brace for serious tax increases.
Once they start issuing bonds,banks will reduce even more of their lending funds.
You can dismiss what you wish and bet all you want. if the gov't is starting to get broke,then Yes,the recession has yet to hit Kenya. It is just the beginning.
I totally agree with Tusker. Keep dollars,find companies that seem to understand the meaning of this is not the time to go on a spending spree.
|
|
Wazua
»
Investor
»
Stocks
»
Prediction: NSE Index will be sub 2,000 by year's end.
Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.
|