jmichi wrote:I greatly admire and appreciate your topnotch analysis of nse stocks. Kindly, I would love to see you analyse kre and insurance firms in general. Much appreciated.
I know I'm not the O.G himuselfu but hope this helps;
I find it easier to break listed insurers into 4 groups.
I only consider dividends and balance sheets.
1.Re-insurers
There's one, Kenya Re a consistent dividend payer. Solid balance sheet. No debt.
2.Kenyan domiciled Insurance Holding Groups
Jubilee- Consistent dividend payer, with a clear dividend policy. Impeccable balance sheet.
Regionally diversified insurance subsidiaries and diversified investments (from fiber optic network to farmers choice)
CIC- Mostly consistent dividend payer, solid balance sheet but some debt linked to Kiambu land.
Regionally diversified insurance subsidiaries.
Britam- Nil dividends in about a decade.
Solid balance sheet.
Regionally diversified insurance subsidiaries.
3.Majority Foreign Owned Kenyan Insurance Subsidiaries
Liberty- Somewhat consistent dividend record. Solid balance sheet.
Sanlam- Long dividend draught.
Solid, smaller smaller balance sheet with some debt(previous commercial debt paid off by rights proceeds).
4.Kenyan Banks That have Insurance Subsidiaries.
NCBA- Newly fully acquired AIG.
Consistent dividend payer, Superior dividend yield. Balance sheet is solid.
Equity - Has a fast growing 2 year old insurer.
Consistent dividend payer.
Solid balance sheet.
Coop owns a significant portion of CIC and has also lent it a significant amount.
Personal opinions
Considering current prices;
Kenya Re is a buy.
Kenyan Domiciled Insurance Holding Groups-Jubilee's balance sheet & management & shareholders respect are unequaled but it's pricey vs dividend yield.
CIC- is worth a look, they'll eventually sell the land.
Foreign Owned Kenyan Insurance Subsidiaries.
Liberty is good value at no more than 12.
Sanlam- With the rights issue injection might be good value at no more than 10.
Kenyan Banks With Insurance Subsidiaries
Historically these beat pure play insurers hands down when it comes to dividend payouts, consistency of profits.
Only consider pure play insurers if you already hold these.
Also note:
1.Jubilee owns a minority part of Kenya Re.
2.Jubilee, Sanlam & Allianz run a combined general insurance operation in Kenya.
3.To the best of my knowledge the Sanlam entity that does asset management isn't owned by the listed entity.