Meanwhile, the honchos at Standard Bank (SA) with their colleagues at CFC Stanbic are sticking to their guns on the bull case for BBK....
A fair set of Q2:13 results given the context: Our first read of Barclays Bank Kenya’s Q2 results was not simple with headline net income down 10% y/y but up 25% q/q on one-off restructuring charges; and the stock’s initial c2% fall probably reflected this as it traded. Adjusting for this, underlying net income was marginally down 4% y/y and 5% q/q which in a low visibility Q2 operating environment would seem fair to us. In a sense, we see support for the stock’s defensiveness in these numbers.
Still solid by new capital requirements : The c700bps headline fall in CAR to c15% is due to cKsh60bn additional RWA on our calculations to reflect operational risk. While we believe the bank’s relative capital strength is well known and accepted by the market, we suspect that in reality, the new capital requirement with a minimum 10.5% core capital to total RWA buys most larger banks some interim breathing space.
Option on asset growth drip-feeding : It’s the tone rather than the numbers that makes a difference in Barclays Q2 disclosure as we see it. We see some support to stronger and selective asset growth in the bank’s highlight of its alignment with asset-driven South African parent, and its participation in the USD5bn facility to Kenya’s largest energy generator is a case in point.
Headline EPS cut hides underlying strength : Our forecast review is mostly a rebalancing exercise, which consists in a strong cut in NOI partly compensated by better run-rate guided NII and flat operating expenses. The one-off restructuring charge alone, which we estimate at Ksh850m for the year, reduces our FY13E EPS by 6%. Our new FY13E net income forecast is cKsh9.3 EPS or an EPS Ksh1.71 from Ksh1.98. We also cut dividend pay-out trimmed by 3pts to 55% to reflect management’s more upbeat stance on asset growth.
Reiterate BUY, TP Ksh21 : The bears of the stock may pick on headline moving parts, especially when going through the numbers. Headline relative valuation may also not help, and we would be the first to admit that Barclays is not cheap at FY13E P/E of 10.1x and P/B of 2.8x. We argue that this is justified by the solid and defensive profile, reiterate BUY.
SBG Securities (Pty) Ltd | 4th Floor | 2 Exchange Square | 85 Maude Street | Sandown | Sandton | 2196