wazua Sat, May 9, 2026
Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Log In

23 Pages«<1415161718>»
Thread for aethists/agnostics.
drzhivago
#151 Posted : Saturday, October 13, 2012 12:06:06 PM
Rank: Member

Joined: 11/21/2007
Posts: 38
hamburglar wrote:
NO MORE OF THAT. AND I REST.


Good, now that we've got all that venom out of our systems, let's now get back to doing productive things that we could have been doing instead of having this trivial online fight in the first place...

No hard feelings, it seems like we both agree that humanity and the need for civility and progress for mankind is bigger than both our inflated egos combined.....I know my ego can be big sometimes, but I have reasons for that.....Sometimes the ego comes out as a defense mechanism and we both went down that route with all the back and forth "pleasantries" that we exchanged....They came wrapped in colorful language too, which is nice as we approach this festive season....Laughing out loudly

You sound like a level headed guy, I will give you that, I can even see myself having a cold beer with you if we ever cross paths, but we need to check the egos at the door lest we get into another shouting match where bragging and "I am better than you complexes", take center stage instead of sensible talk . We both failed miserably on that front, but it's ok, it happens to the best of us, even monkeys fall off trees every now and then...I will admit that, figuratively, I took a hard fall from the tree and really hurt my butt cheeks....lol...But that fall will not keep me from going back up that tree....I crack myself up, maybe I should take my show on the road......Have a good weekend dude....Keep doing the good work....Difference of opinion can be healthy sometimes :)
[/quote]

Sorry to come back here but I hadn’t seen this. I wasn’t having a fight with you, I have no reason to do that and have no hard feelings either. I was just being forceful in trying to demonstrate that you cannot conclusively make such bold claims (or denials) without comprehensive and valid knowledge of all the phenomena that’s been associated with your claims (or denial). This is the problem of both atheism and conventional theism and where agnosticism beats them hands down. And for the record, I have no problem with atheism. In fact I find it’s quite bold to come out in the open and defy convention, ask the uncomfortable questions. Even as the others condemn you and shout you down, deep down they know they long for answers to these very questions but have been too afraid to confront. For this, you move humanity forward, for that I applaud you. Atheism becomes a problem (and a religion in its own right) when it becomes an end in itself, when it claims absolute authority over that which it claims. It thus becomes yet another prison that parameterizes the confines beyond which the human mind cannot expand, rather than the means through which man seeks freedom to reach his higher ideals. This is the kind of militant atheism that will brook no challenge and appeals to the lower human nature, that which seeks to have authority above it, something to believe in and hence the need for prophets (including the modern day Dawkins and associates). Asking questions is a good thing; in fact it shows that you are not afraid to think (outside the box). But once you start asking these hard questions, stopping short of deeply satisfying answers can be such an anti-climax, don’t you think?

I brought in the quantum mechanics angle to demonstrate (and perhaps brag a little smile) that the objective reality you experience and base your life and beliefs (or lack of) about life on a daily basis has been challenged scientifically. This is the reality that tells you that the sun raises in the east and sets in the west, that the ground beneath your feet is static and solid. These things are not literally true, yet we have constructed and live our lives as if they were. Heheh, now this is where I see people’s eyes glaze over as their brains shut down; Information overload! System crash! … I’ve got to go home and have dinner and play with my kids and feed the dog and perhaps make love to my wife and go to work tomorrow … totally oblivious of what’s really going on here. And on and on our mundane lives go on and eventually we die as we are destined to and who knows what happens thereafter.
youcan'tstopusnow
#152 Posted : Saturday, October 13, 2012 3:00:17 PM
Rank: Chief

Joined: 3/24/2010
Posts: 6,779
Location: Black Africa
hamburglar are you for the death penalty? What about corporal punishment? I am for the latter but simaanishi vita kwa mtoto. But I just don't believe in that 'time out/go to the corner' stuff. But as you are fond of saying, to each their own. As for the former, I think it should be replaced with life+extremely hard labour+many strokes of the cane. Hehe. No I'm not a sadist.
GOD BLESS YOUR LIFE
Nabwire
#153 Posted : Sunday, October 14, 2012 7:30:25 AM
Rank: Veteran

Joined: 7/22/2011
Posts: 1,325
Hamburglar congrats on graduating from Wharton, just wondering why you hardly comment in the Investors section. I would like to know what your portofolio entails, someone once said that the best capital gains can be found in stocks with market caps of $50 million and below, then went ahead and said that he wouldnt touch stocks on the pinksheets, abit confusing coz most $50 mil and under are OTC, he wouldnt give more info. I'm trying to squeeze out info, sorry for derailing the convo
Sufficiently Philanga....thropic
#154 Posted : Sunday, October 14, 2012 12:56:38 PM
Rank: Elder

Joined: 9/23/2010
Posts: 2,225
Location: Sundowner,Amboseli
@Nabwire,was wondering too why @Hamburger,who claimed in this very thread that he is a CFA and has an MBA to back it up has never commented on anything Finance and prefers attacking God insteadLaughing out loudly Wish he told us he has a Masters in matters Atheism or stuff like thatsmile
@the burger,how about you tell us about black and scholes or MM's Dividend irrelevance theory of 1961. And while at it,maybe you can help us derive the formula,well,for both!
Me thinks @Nabwire should have been the one to parade her papers here,at least coz i read her informative posts,and yes,she's one bright young gal with, a bright future!!!@Hamburger,care to learn from her?smile
@SufficientlyP
grolut
#155 Posted : Tuesday, October 16, 2012 10:44:05 AM
Rank: Member

Joined: 9/2/2010
Posts: 563
Location: Embakasi
A light touch on this debate. Be warned there is some profanity, do not click if easily offended.

http://theoatmeal.com/comics/religion
In a place where thought is abandoned, freedom can become a curse.
hamburglar
#156 Posted : Tuesday, October 16, 2012 10:41:02 PM
Rank: Member

Joined: 12/17/2011
Posts: 887
Nabwire wrote:
Hamburglar congrats on graduating from Wharton, just wondering why you hardly comment in the Investors section. I would like to know what your portofolio entails, someone once said that the best capital gains can be found in stocks with market caps of $50 million and below, then went ahead and said that he wouldnt touch stocks on the pinksheets, abit confusing coz most $50 mil and under are OTC, he wouldnt give more info. I'm trying to squeeze out info, sorry for derailing the convo



Nabwire, we meet again, always nice to hear from you....Reason that I hardly ever comment in the investors section is because I stopped working in that industry a few years back...Formal employment is tantamount to glorified slavery. I decided to become a developer and that was the best decision that I ever made in my life. The ROI for real estate development in Kenya are phenomenal.

Anyway, to answer your question, and I am surprised you even asked this question because with your knowledge, I would think that you would already know this.

Through my experience, I always found out that small companies were always been a good if not great way to make a killing off of the stock market.....The one thing that I know that is almost always certain is that the biggest gaining stocks are bound to be OTC stocks......The profit potential of penny stocks is great....

I will give you an example of a company that I was familiar with called Synutra International, Inc. Nasdaq: HYUT.... This is a great OTC stock. ....Hardly a few years back, Synutra was a dairy and nutritional products operation that morphed into a billion dollar corp....It went from OTC to the NASDAQ Stock Market bringing with it over 100% gains in just a couple of months.....My point is that this happens all the time and it’s how some of the best investors in the world became so rich .....They did it by purchasing shares for pennies on the dollar which we can all do if we have the time to invest on it, and then turning around and selling them for $10, $15 or $20 and hauling in big returns.

OTC's stock can be very rewarding even when the economy is at a lull. I know for a fact that small stocks outperformed TBills, the S$P Nad bonds about 80% of the time.....The reason that the person you were talking to said that they would not touch them is probably because many of them aren’t even traded on a major exchange.

But like I said Nabwire, I have been out of the loop for a while and don't even trade at all anymore since I found the secret to riches is in Kenya's real estate, so i might not be the most knowledgeable guy anymore....I have seen people here including this Philanga character that have very deep insights in the industry and I think they might have more in depth information...
hamburglar
#157 Posted : Tuesday, October 16, 2012 11:09:39 PM
Rank: Member

Joined: 12/17/2011
Posts: 887
youcan'tstopusnow wrote:
hamburglar are you for the death penalty? What about corporal punishment? I am for the latter but simaanishi vita kwa mtoto. But I just don't believe in that 'time out/go to the corner' stuff. But as you are fond of saying, to each their own. As for the former, I think it should be replaced with life+extremely hard labour+many strokes of the cane. Hehe. No I'm not a sadist.


Youcantstopusnow, I am not for or against the death penalty, I just think it depends onthe situation. I think that there have been mistakes in the past that were made and innocent people were executed as a result...There is always new technology coming out, so I think that these people that are to be executed should be locked up and whenver there is a doubt, have that new technology prove or disprove the case....That way, I feel like we would be giving everybody a fair chance.....

But don't get me wrong, there are some monsters in this world that should not be allowed to live amongst us. If somebody of sound mind happens to commit a heinous crime like raping and killing a child, and there is documentary evidence beyond a shadow of doubt, then I wouldn't oppose to them taking a trip down the green mile to meet their fate. The judicial system is not full proof. I just think that it depends on the situation....

I am completely against corporal punishment though...The time out/go to the corner and or vita kwa watoto are both wrong in my eyes because they both constitute some form of punishment...Punishment in my opinion serves to instill fear in kids instead of trying to rectify the problem...If you beat a kid or put them in timeout, I don't think they will understand why what they did is wrong....What that does is have them avoid doing the wrong thing because of the repurcussions and the fear of punishment and not neccessarily because they understand that what they did was wrong...

People underestimate kids' power of undestandning. Kids are not stupid, they have a great capacity for understadning things as early as age 2. Punishment has no place in my world, I think people should start talking and teaching kids about right and wrong instead of applying corporal punishment and or time outs...It's better for the child to understand why something they did is wrong instead of him/her avoiding to do the wrong thing out of fear of getting punished....If they fear punishment, they will never understand why what they are being punished for is wrong.....Just my two cents, but then again, like everything else, everybody is different. I have seen kids that were never beaten or put in timeout succeed in life and some fail in life vice versa for kids that were punished one way or the other....At the end of the day, I think it's about the values that are instilled in the child that matter....For me, I think those values can still be instilled without any sort of punishment.
hamburglar
#158 Posted : Tuesday, October 16, 2012 11:12:04 PM
Rank: Member

Joined: 12/17/2011
Posts: 887
ChessMaster wrote:
@the atheists I am always intrigued by your views.I've copied this from some other discussion in wazua hoping to get answers here. I struggle with these very questions so I hope you can share your opinions with me if you don't mind.

Q1.How do you decide what's good?From what values or beliefs do you base them on?Is a sadist or a psychopath wrong in deriving pleasure from doing hurting others. I ask this because what if you too have been indoctrinated into the belief of good and evil stemming from the pleasure and pain principle.

Q2.Personally I believe you can't be free as a human until you try to resolve the issues pertaining to your existence in this world.If this applies to you,how do you resolve those issues?We don't know where we come from or where we are heading but have faith under our different religions, but as we are all here how do you explain you're existence? I ask these because randomness doesn't produce consistent results and patterns like the universe we live in shows us exists.

Q3.I have also thought about the suffering in this world.I always reach a point which I admittedly can't figure out. Without discomfort,can we know comfort? Without suffering,can we know pleasure? Wouldn't the alternative be us being numb or like computers just being feed instructions?What about prisons on earth,what's your opinion on the matter and on crime?And how much suffering do you cause others with your very existence?I myself see my life and think about all those people who have been screwed over and continue to be screwed over just for a few individuals like us to have the luxury of posting.

Q4.I don't think man's problems stem from materialistic things although they do play a huge role in it.I think they stem from his heart.What's your opinion on that?

Q5.I believe that God exists,so bear with me. Assume just for the sake of discussion that he does,do you think as man we would be able to comprehend his ways through our minds?We haven't even figured out the building blocks of the universe. We haven't even been to another planet let alone solar system. Lets be realistic,we can't even feed ourselves as a planet. How then if only men can't find a common ground between ourselves can we find God?



Chessmaster, quite interesting questions/observations you have raised...I will try and answer you in due time...Or maybe my atheist friends can chip in....
youcan'tstopusnow
#159 Posted : Wednesday, October 17, 2012 12:45:48 AM
Rank: Chief

Joined: 3/24/2010
Posts: 6,779
Location: Black Africa
I find your views on punishment very interesting. As always, a pleasure...
GOD BLESS YOUR LIFE
Scubidu
#160 Posted : Sunday, October 21, 2012 1:42:56 AM
Rank: Veteran

Joined: 9/4/2009
Posts: 700
Location: Nairobi
Just stumbled onto this topic and thot it was quite interesting reading the different opinions. I did find myself questioning my belief system in 2008 (having been brought up a roman catholic) when i started my own spiritual journey. Though since then I haven't really been able to find the answers (if there were any) i was looking for despite having experimented with most beliefs systems from new age to islam, hinduism and the various schools of christianity since '08. I felt they all had their shortcomings as institutions, but each had a moral code that could be blended to enabling me to refine my interaction with people. But I was interested by something @tycho mentioned in an earlier post on a new kind of theism and if i belong to that group.

tycho wrote:
@hamburglar, you are saying that you strive to do good, and this goodness is a product of nurture and is enforced by your conscience.

The good you do involves giving alms, and curing cancer.

You are mortal and weak or mortal but 'strong'.

Talk about nurture is talk about culture and in your case you are saying that goodness is a cultural construct. By pledging loyalty to conscience you are pledging loyalty to the culture in your head.

Now I wonder, isn't this a kind of theism?

Of what import is conscious decision making if it doesn't offer opportunity to choose?

Surely, not questioning your conscience is a kind of death!

Your sense of goodness involves giving alms. Obviously this involves some social stratification. 'I am better than'. This caste system is responsible for millions of children every day. And I believe is a contributor to cancer cases, and many other deaths. Yet you support it with your 'goodness'.

But you are also busy working for a cancer cure. Will you do it alone? Of course not! Now start working with others in projects that are longer than your life spans. And say that there are no ideals to strive for and obey without question. Your goodness immediately disappears.

You need 'God' in order to speak. Philosophy dies without God. For philosophy is about seeing and knowing everything, and in extension, doing everything.


To me pledging one's loyalty to my own conscience is pledging loyalty to the culture in your head - but whose the author of my culture? My culture has been molded by religious upbringing and structure of compulsory christian-oriented schooling, where one is forced into a particular cultural construct where some questions are more relevant than others. If there's no creator then who created the universe and if there's a creator who created the creator. I have no doubt my moral code has been shaped by my childhood upbringing, but that had limitations particularly when existential questions such as why there's suffering in the world have no satisfying answer.

I once watched a movie by Michael Tsarion where he questions whether people have the absolute right to do what they do (no matter how supposedly "evil" it is) and that everyone has the responsibility only for themselves. There was an interesting quote in the same movie by Vernon Linwood Howard (1918-1992) saying "we can accept God becoming man to save man, but not man becoming God to save himself". To me that sounded like the crux of the situation, but off course with regard to this thread i'm not so sure which category i'd fit in: aethists, agnostic, catholic, hindu, muslim, new ager.

The novel the Siren of the Titan has a phenomenon known as a chrono-synclastic infundibulum, which is loosely defined... as "those places (perhaps in your mind)... where all the different kinds of truths fit together". Perhaps that's a new unconventional religion or I'm perhaps just bidding my time (so-called fence-sitting) waiting for either life's experiences or human society place me in the most agreeable category for my current condition. Either way i think @tycho was on to something that I personally won't mind discussing further.
“We are the middle children of history man, no purpose or place. We have no great war, no great depression. Our great war is a spiritual war, our great depression is our lives!" – Tyler Durden
23 Pages«<1415161718>»
Forum Jump  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Copyright © 2026 Wazua.co.ke. All Rights Reserved.