Wazua
»
Club SK
»
Life
»
Thread for aethists/agnostics.
Rank: Member Joined: 9/27/2006 Posts: 506
|
maka wrote:What if indeed there is a God and at 1 point in time the world does come to an end and judgement thereafter takes place,would the atheist admit they were wrong? What if we are living in a computer simulation called the Matrix? What if the Nazis had won WW2? You can ask what if questions all you like...
|
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/17/2011 Posts: 887
|
NO MORE OF THAT. AND I REST. [/quote] Good, now that we've got all that venom out of our systems, let's now get back to doing productive things that we could have been doing instead of having this trivial online fight in the first place...
No hard feelings, it seems like we both agree that humanity and the need for civility and progress for mankind is bigger than both our inflated egos combined.....I know my ego can be big sometimes, but I have reasons for that.....Sometimes the ego comes out as a defense mechanism and we both went down that route with all the back and forth "pleasantries" that we exchanged....They came wrapped in colorful language too, which is nice as we approach this festive season....
You sound like a level headed guy, I will give you that, I can even see myself having a cold beer with you if we ever cross paths, but we need to check the egos at the door lest we get into another shouting match where bragging and "I am better than you complexes", take center stage instead of sensible talk . We both failed miserably on that front, but it's ok, it happens to the best of us, even monkeys fall off trees every now and then...I will admit that, figuratively, I took a hard fall from the tree and really hurt my butt cheeks....lol...But that fall will not keep me from going back up that tree....I crack myself up, maybe I should take my show on the road......Have a good weekend dude....Keep doing the good work....Difference of opinion can be healthy sometimes :)
|
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/17/2011 Posts: 887
|
maka wrote:What if indeed there is a God and at 1 point in time the world does come to an end and judgement thereafter takes place,would the atheist admit they were wrong? If that ever happened, that would be a great opportunity to ask this god guy some very serious questions about his shoddy job as god....I would love to come face to face with him so that I can ask him why he let children starve to death when he could had intervened and saved them and why he did not give us a cure to all these diseases that are killing people everyday...I would love that opportunity to question his work on a lot of things....If he is unhappy with my questions and send me to hell, then I would gladly go to hell because I don't want to be associated with a god like that in the first place who had the ability to end suffering on earth and did nothing about it..That is not the kind of person I want to be around....
If his priority would be to send me to hell to burn for eternity instead of answering my questions, then I would tell him to his face that he is an evil man/thing for inflicting such pain as burning somebody on his "child" just because I had questions....If seeking answers from him is sin that is punishable by burning in eternal fire, then I will gladly walk into hell and high five satan because I don't want to be in a heaven full of hypocrites....
What have atheists done wrong other than question the existance of your god? Most atheists are more righteous than a lot of these scambug pastors that we see in churches everyday....Atheists haven't done anything wrong, they just don't believe in a deity who throws temper tantrums when people question him or when he doesn't get his way...Maybe he needs to take anger management classes that way he can learn to control his temper and also take some courses on conflict management where maybe he can learn to dialogue with people who have a different opinion of him without burning them or flooding the earth and killing everybody.....Your god has some serious issues that he needs to fix before he can judge anybody.....
|
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 3/30/2010 Posts: 176
|
The folly of thinking you know it all...
A Long Island businessman in the 1930s bought an expensive brass barometer to mount in his home. However, when the man pulled the instrument out of the box and started to hang it, the arrow that indicated current weather conditions was pointing hard to "Hurricane."
Angrily, he pounded his palm on the glass face of the barometer. The arrow didn't move. He shook it and then banged it on the table. The arrow still didn't move. This thing was obviously defective. So the next morning he fired off a nasty letter to the manufacturer and dropped it in a mailbox on his way to work in Manhattan.
But sure enough, a storm did roar through Long Island that day. And when he drove home in the afternoon, his house was destroyed ... in a hurricane.
You see, there is absolute truth and there is deception.
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 10/4/2006 Posts: 13,823 Location: Nairobi
|
hamburglar wrote:maka wrote:What if indeed there is a God and at 1 point in time the world does come to an end and judgement thereafter takes place,would the atheist admit they were wrong? If that ever happened, that would be a great opportunity to ask this god guy some very serious questions about his shoddy job as god....I would love to come face to face with him so that I can ask him why he let children starve to death when he could had intervened and saved them and why he did not give us a cure to all these diseases that are killing people everyday...I would love that opportunity to question his work on a lot of things....If he is unhappy with my questions and send me to hell, then I would gladly go to hell because I don't want to be associated with a god like that in the first place who had the ability to end suffering on earth and did nothing about it..That is not the kind of person I want to be around....
If his priority would be to send me to hell to burn for eternity instead of answering my questions, then I would tell him to his face that he is an evil man/thing for inflicting such pain as burning somebody on his "child" just because I had questions....If seeking answers from him is sin that is punishable by burning in eternal fire, then I will gladly walk into hell and high five satan because I don't want to be in a heaven full of hypocrites....
What have atheists done wrong other than question the existance of your god? Most atheists are more righteous than a lot of these scambug pastors that we see in churches everyday....Atheists haven't done anything wrong, they just don't believe in a deity who throws temper tantrums when people question him or when he doesn't get his way...Maybe he needs to take anger management classes that way he can learn to control his temper and also take some courses on conflict management where maybe he can learn to dialogue with people who have a different opinion of him without burning them or flooding the earth and killing everybody.....Your god has some serious issues that he needs to fix before he can judge anybody..... the one thing that astounds me is that atheists always ask - Why does God allow (poverty, war, diseases e.t.c), something that they themselves do not experience since most atheist live relatively good lives but fault God for the sufferings of others HOWEVER on the flip side, those in war, poverty and disease trust God and have faith for the future. secondly... one of the things atheists need to understand is that God does not define 'good' or 'evil' in the human definition of the same - we have max 120 years to live, he does not. its foolish to think of God as a guy who is here to sort you out! We need to understand that God does what he decides to do and he even asks DOES A POT ASK THE POTTER - WHAT ARE YOU DOING? OR WHY DON'T I HAVE HANDLES? OR WHY DID YOU MAKE ME THIS WAY? The potter decides what to do - human beings exist for him and not vice versa. All Mushrooms are edible! Some Mushroom are only edible ONCE!
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 2/23/2009 Posts: 1,626
|
@the atheists I am always intrigued by your views.I've copied this from some other discussion in wazua hoping to get answers here. I struggle with these very questions so I hope you can share your opinions with me if you don't mind. Q1.How do you decide what's good?From what values or beliefs do you base them on?Is a sadist or a psychopath wrong in deriving pleasure from doing hurting others. I ask this because what if you too have been indoctrinated into the belief of good and evil stemming from the pleasure and pain principle. Q2.Personally I believe you can't be free as a human until you try to resolve the issues pertaining to your existence in this world.If this applies to you,how do you resolve those issues?We don't know where we come from or where we are heading but have faith under our different religions, but as we are all here how do you explain you're existence? I ask these because randomness doesn't produce consistent results and patterns like the universe we live in shows us exists. Q3.I have also thought about the suffering in this world.I always reach a point which I admittedly can't figure out. Without discomfort,can we know comfort? Without suffering,can we know pleasure? Wouldn't the alternative be us being numb or like computers just being feed instructions?What about prisons on earth,what's your opinion on the matter and on crime?And how much suffering do you cause others with your very existence?I myself see my life and think about all those people who have been screwed over and continue to be screwed over just for a few individuals like us to have the luxury of posting. Q4.I don't think man's problems stem from materialistic things although they do play a huge role in it.I think they stem from his heart.What's your opinion on that? Q5.I believe that God exists,so bear with me. Assume just for the sake of discussion that he does,do you think as man we would be able to comprehend his ways through our minds?We haven't even figured out the building blocks of the universe. We haven't even been to another planet let alone solar system. Lets be realistic,we can't even feed ourselves as a planet. How then if only men can't find a common ground between ourselves can we find God? Uncertainty is certain.Let go
|
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 12/17/2011 Posts: 887
|
Dia wrote:The folly of thinking you know it all...
A Long Island businessman in the 1930s bought an expensive brass barometer to mount in his home. However, when the man pulled the instrument out of the box and started to hang it, the arrow that indicated current weather conditions was pointing hard to "Hurricane."
Angrily, he pounded his palm on the glass face of the barometer. The arrow didn't move. He shook it and then banged it on the table. The arrow still didn't move. This thing was obviously defective. So the next morning he fired off a nasty letter to the manufacturer and dropped it in a mailbox on his way to work in Manhattan.
But sure enough, a storm did roar through Long Island that day. And when he drove home in the afternoon, his house was destroyed ... in a hurricane.
You see, there is absolute truth and there is deception.
What's your point? All the story says is that somebody bought a defective barometer in 1930 and if you ask me, had every right to write a letter to the manufacturer to complain about the defective product they sold him.....What's wrong with that? Then you say that his house was destroyed in a subsequent hurricane and it seems like he was left homeless...Am not sure what that has to do with anything....What does that have to do with the topic at hand?
Or are you trying to imply that god was punishing him for maybe writing a complaint letter? help me out here.... We have established that your god is an angry man and loves punishing people and making them suffer everytime he feels slighted, is that what's going on here as well? Was he throwing yet another temper tantrum at the person who rightfully wrote a letter to complain about being sold to a faulty product? If that's the case, then it seems like this god guy has even more issues than I originally thought...He has one hell of a temper......I wouldn't want to be around a bad tempered guy like that who when angry can turn you into a pillar of salt for just looking over your shoulder.....
|
|
|
Rank: New-farer Joined: 7/16/2011 Posts: 59
|
Quote:Question everything, don't just beleive what you are told. That's why we atheists rely on logic and reason, that way we can't easily be fooled...You won't ever meet a gullible atheist, because we question and reason things out. .Naive and gullible theists are a dime a dozen...Theists will believe anything as long as it's in that silly book.. ..That's why the church and pastors and priests and all those other religious people are a billion dollar business, it's easy to fleece theists because they have been taught to never question, just believe. Am of the opinion you question everything but you do not seek answers at least from a practical perspective.you have asserted that you rely on logic and science.I challenged you to consciously examine your daily actions and quantify how many are logical and are based on the scientific method.They will be quite few. Human beings are not designed to be purely logical as you seem to imply as we would be similar to robots. Stephen Hawkins is a priest to the atheist.He and his publishers have curved out an industry and are milking it seriously much more than the priests.He comes up with/ a book/feature every say one year.He knows both Theists and Atheist will buy.Theists, to try and disapprove him;Atheist to affirm their position.Don't expect his equations to make you understand evil e.g What motivated that young man who shot the The same applies for the likes of Dawkins,Harris etc.They are well established in industry. Quote:The nonsense you just wrote above there proves my point, that if this god of yours really exists, he needs to take anger management classes, Logically,you should consider He has. Quote:@hamburglar, you are saying that you strive to do good, and this goodness is a product of nurture and is enforced by your conscience.
The good you do involves giving alms, and curing cancer.
You are mortal and weak or mortal but 'strong'.
Talk about nurture is talk about culture and in your case you are saying that goodness is a cultural construct. By pledging loyalty to conscience you are pledging loyalty to the culture in your head. Quote:Now I wonder, isn't this a kind of theism? I This is good thinking,Tycho.This is the same dilemma ,Richard Dawkins ,faced or is facing.I'm surprised Hamburglar you did not bother using the explanations He has come up with. I want to let you know that I don't know jack about quantum physics. Ok so you know classical physics?Hamburgler your beliefs I take it are not driven by science but by the fact that you cannot reconcile the fact that an All loving Creature can allow pain and suffering without intervening. If God exists then He must be Immutable,study what this means. In addition ,your knowledge of biblical narratives and concepts is wanting.Where did God turn someone into a pillar of salt?
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 8/11/2010 Posts: 1,588
|
I thought we had finished this?
Why do we keep going round and round in circles?
Are we addicted to circles?
|
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 2/20/2009 Posts: 658
|
YesuWangu wrote:I thought we had finished this?
Why do we keep going round and round in circles?
Are we addicted to circles? Yeeeessssss!!!!!
|
|
|
Wazua
»
Club SK
»
Life
»
Thread for aethists/agnostics.
Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.
|