I don't think that KQ's poor share performance prior to late 2004 is an appropriate comparison to the situation faced by KenRe today. For one, the period from 1995 to the year 2002 was generally a
lost decade (or as near to one as it can be) for the entire stock market. There were very few bright spots for the whole market in those years. Most companies during those years traded at less than book value and with dividend yields of above 10%. For example , in 2001 Barclays Bank had an EPS of Kshs 16 with a DPS of Kshs 14, yet at 31.12.2001, the price was Kshs 72.50. (I obtained these figures from the NSE HandBook circa 2005). In that sense KQ was not unique.
Of course KQ also suffered from the risk generally associated with airlines. This perception was pretty much confirmed in the minds of many, with the January 2000 crash of its Airbus off the coast of Abidjan (Outtaraland). It was therefore not surprising that, KQ just like today traded at a lower PE than the blue chips.
On the other hand Kenya Re today is almost
alone (if we ignore agriculturals) in trading below its Net Book Value. Note that this is a company with no loans - Indeed it had more than Kshs
3 billion in
cash or near cash on its books as at 30.06.2010. It has been
rated at
AA and
BB+ by International Rating Agencies for its claims paying ability in Kshs and US$ respectively. This is a
better rating than its private sector rival, East Africa Re which just
increased its PAT for 2010 by more than 50%.
With the above facts, it is therefore hard to justify a trading price which is just about
half its projected 2010 NAV and PE of less than 4.
Indeed I postulate that KNRE
does not actually need to do anything extraordinary for the share to at least go up by 20%. This is because investors hardly expect anything out of it. Hence, should the Mgt and B.o.D
just be seen to be waking up from their slumber, I would not be surprised by a more than disproportionate rise in the share price.
selah wrote:KQ remained suppressed for more than 8yrs after listing, it started edging up after announcing a record profit growth of 198% in 2004/2005 FY.
Kenya Re on the other hand has been performing dismally since the listing the management has not shown its willingness to grow its bottom line in tandem with its competitors.
Unless the New MD does something out of the ordinary I dont see the share edging up like KQ did.